Sci-Fi Debate Club

If you’ve seen this week’s episode of my web series, then you know about my Sci-Fi Debate Club. If you missed it, take a look…

We didn’t plan it. We didn’t mean for it to happen. But when two of more nerds are gathered together, nerdy…geeky…dorky debates are bound to ensue! And yes… they can get rather heated at times. We nerds are passionate about our fandoms (to say the least.) But I think we can all agree that we are united in the way we love. We love with intensity. We love with all we have.

Here are some of the hottest debates (not all are science fiction related) in the nerd community…

#1 -Star Wars vs. Star Trek

8176b63fa786a294103875561d0e5c81
Photo from FuriousFanboys.com

Do you prefer a galaxy far, far away full of rebels and stormtroopers, blasters and lightsabers, the Dark side and the Light side. Or do you tend to lean towards the order of Starfleet. The uniforms, the space exploration, the strange new worlds and civilizations? Personally, I don’t like to choose. I grew up with both of them in my life from a very young age and have never known a time when there wasn’t something to look forward to in the world of one or both of them. That being said, Star Wars does hold an extra special place in my heart. I cried when I saw the newest trailer for The Force Awakens and none of the Star Trek’s have elicited quite that response. But I do love both world greatly.

#2 – Would sex with Superman kill Lois Lane?

337371b457684f7079d85065e4b416a6
Photo from io9

Gotta admit that I haven’t spent a lot of time thinking about this one. But I sorta think they’d find a way to make it work. Love will conquer all… even super powered nether regions.

#3 – Who’s the best Doctor?

3ced4464bc04ef6a8a1d3998554ff6f7

This is a case of…why choose? Although, if I really did have to pick between all of Doctors that have ever been, I’d definitely choose the tenth Doctor, played by the incomparable David Tennant. (I guess I chose after all!)

#4 – Mac vs. PC or Android

3d3971b8e1625c16a0a4efec2985d723

This is more of a geeky tech debate. But it’s one that is had often and can get heated. Mac people are loyal and unswayed in their devotion to the apple. I used to be unflinchingly Mac oriented. And when it comes to computers, my loyalty stands. Now when it comes to phones…different story. 4 years ago when I finally upgraded to a smart phone, I was ready to take my place in the iPhone community, but alas, T-mobile did not carry iPhones at the time and that is the service my family uses. So I was forced to join the world of Samsung instead… and I’ve never looked back.

#5 – Bale vs. Keaton

bc25dad4b03c5432441419be95becea8

What this boils down to is more of a best-Batman-ever-debate. Contenders: Adam West, Michael Keaton, Val Kilmer, George Clooney, Kevin Conroy, Christian Bale & Ben Affleck (I guess we still have to wait and see about that last one.) I’m firmly in the Kevin Conroy camp. For those of you not in the know, Conroy voiced Batman on the beloved Batman: The Animated Series from the 90’s. The same series that hosted Mark Hamill’s icon voicing of the Joker (another popular debate among nerds: Best Joker ever.) Keaton comes in as a solid second for me (Batman Returns is one of my faves…I love Pfeiffer’s Catwoman!)

#6 – Marvel vs. DC

794950642aa9488951983515de9d60cc
Photo from Kweeper.com

This is an issue where I really don’t want to take a stand. I could argue passionately for both. Though Marvel’s immersive world is just so unique and impressive right now. I grew up on the Batman and Superman animated series. And Superman has long been my favorite superhero of all time. Now as for favorite superhero team, I love The Avengers and I also really love X-Men. But my favorite villain is Harley Quinn. My imaginary superhero boyfriend is Captain America. But my imaginary best friend is Catwoman. See… I’m all over the place. I dip my toe in both pools and I just don’t wanna choose…so I won’t!

#7 – Game of Thrones vs. Lord of the Rings

87dd0636db66f2768a905b239eebcea0

This is a no brainer for me. One is a pop culture phenomenon. The show that brought dragons to the mainstream audience. That’s an amazing feat, to be sure. But the other is a piece of classic literature. A set of beloved stories that a parent can pass down to their children. An epic tale of hope and fellowship. An author who inspired the other so much that he went and added R’s in his name for that very reason. Any other argument is made invalid by that fact alone. (mic dropped…Liz out!)

#8 – Pirates vs. Ninjas

d4dc7911d99b043f393b7a2da0bbb8e5
Photo from baconbag.com

Ok… we have to talk first about where and why and in what time period are these pirates fighting the ninjas. Are they allowed to bring their pistols to the sword fight?  Cause pirates fight dirty, while ninjas are all about tradition. Though my coworker just brought up a good point…the pirates would probably be inebriated for the fight. So there’s that.

#9 – Captain Kirk vs. Captain Picard

f03b12e173b83ccf3090f3c78e7f2c94

There is a greater debate along these lines, who’s the best Starfleet Captain of all? Are you a Kirk fan? A Picard follower? Is it Captain Sisko that really gets you? Perhaps Janeway is the lady captain for you? Or maybe….nope that’s it! (Sorry Scott Bakula… I love you, but Enterprise doesn’t count.) Personally I’m a Captain Picard girl. I was a child of the 80’s and a preteen of the 90’s. And my parents l-l-loved Star Trek: The Next Generation. We used to watch it together all the time. So there’s a great deal of nostalgia and warm fuzzies attached to Jean-Luc. And while I really enjoy all the other Star Trek series as well and think they have stellar captains at the helm, it’s Picard for me!

#10 – Did Han shoot first?

6dbcdcd1c15ba2cb09a2e8c86297e4b1
Artwork by Fitz Fitzpatrick

This one is less a debate and more of a sore spot for hardcore fans of Star Wars. See… here’s the story. Star Wars was released in 1977. Beautiful, iconic, practically perfect in every way! 20 years later, George Lucas remastered his masterpiece to include some new things. Including, but not limited to, the scene between Greedo and Han Solo in the Mos Eisley cantina. In the original, untainted version of Star Wars, Han shoots Greedo, killing him and thus ending their conversation. This gave Han a cold-blooded killer persona. One that the Maker did not intend for Han. So when the remastered editions came out, George took the chance to set the record straight and added CGI footage of Greedo shooting first, missing and then Han shooting and killing him afterwards. Fans were unhappy, to say the least (the very least.) In actuality, fans were pissed!! 20 years of believing something about their beloved hero only to have it changed? This isn’t the only thing about the remastered versions that would upset the fans. But George Lucas maintains that Greedo shot first, while fans insist the opposite. Han Solo himself (Harrison Ford) was asked about this nerd debate in a 2014 Reddit conversation. His response…”I don’t know and I don’t care.”

7dffb1fec31aee7952973801ca023912

At the end of the day, we all love and love hard. So what are your thoughts on these very important and pressing issues in the world of nerdy things? Let me know in the comments below!! Even if we disagree, I still love to hear about it!

84f24d4a5c4a82ed3b85f95161e00fbc

4 thoughts on “Sci-Fi Debate Club

  1. Here’s how I’d go with these answers:

    1) Star Wars. I don’t have anything against Star Trek. I’ve watched the movies and TV shows. But I was always a Star Wars fan and would always side with Star Wars in any debate.

    2) No I don’t think it’d kill him. I remember having this conversation with some friends a couple of years ago and we talked about how Superman can shake hands with people and not crush their hands. If he could do that, then pretty sure he would take care of Lois

    3) I tend to be a fan of more classic Who (I started watching all the Who episodes a couple of years ago & aside from a few serials have seen them all) so I would go with the Fourth Doctor Tom Baker. If choosing between the modern ones, I’d go Tennant since he’s one of my favorite actors outside of Who as well.

    4) If we’re choosing computers I’m PC because they’re cheaper and easier to use. Phone wise I’m Apple.

    5) I agree that Kevin Conroy is Batman no doubt. As far as the cinematic, I’d either go Bale or Keeton, although I liked Kilmer in Batman Forever.

    6) This one is tough. I grew up reading both. I was a fan of the X-Men cartoons (and comics) of the 80s and 90s. But also some of my favorite characters are also in DC (Batman, Flash). So I guess I would say both. But I’ll say Marvel is what I would choose as far as films go & DC as far as TV shows

    7) I have read Lord of the Rings. I have watched the films. I have never read Game of Thrones. I have never watched the TV show. So Lord of the Rings it is

    8) This one was one I never really had any problem with. Mainly because i didn’t care one or the other. If I had to choose I’d probably go with ninjas.

    9) Since I’m not really a Star Trek person, again don’t really have one way or the other. Probably I’d go Kirk because of his attitude and the way he would play off of Spock & Bones

    10) I grew up with Han shooting first. He shot first & Greedo never got a shot off.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I just remembered something. Jedi. I’m talkin’… Ewan McGregor as Obi Wan. Mark Hammill. Freakin’ Yoda. SO good.

    So many good quotes. Too many good ones to choose a favorite. New SW can’t get here soon enough!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Um could we really have pretty much the exact same answers for #3, #5, #6, #7, and #9?!?! Sometimes it scares me! Though I have to say that I will always be more of a Trekie than a Star Wars fan. I just love the whole ‘to explore strange new worlds… to godly go where no man has gone before! *Goosebumps*

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s